The Purposes, Organization, and Supervision of Regulators: Implications for Accountability and Liability
Dr Christopher Decker
Decker_PB.pdf (227.98 KB)
The Purposes, Organization, and Supervision of Regulators: Implications for Accountability and Liability
As recent events in the financial sector have demonstrated, the action or inaction of regulators can profoundly affect lives and livelihoods. It follows that regulators must operate within well-designed frameworks of accountability and liability. 
 
In this policy brief, the author advances the theory of 'confirmation bias' to explain recent systematic defective regulatory decision-making and actions, and argues that accountability and liability frameworks for regulators must provide the appropriate incentives for regulators. 

In this respect, it is argued that questions of regulatory accountability and liability cannot be separated from broader questions about the purposes of regulation (why we regulate); the external and internal organization of regulatory agencies (how we regulate); and regulatory oversight and supervision arrangements (who regulates the regulators).

 

ALSO OF INTEREST
Policy Brief
Media Law after Leveson: A view from the coalface

In this policy brief, the Guardian’s Director of Editorial Legal Services Gillian Phillips presents her perspective on the post-Leveson media law landscape, arguing that journalists are being submerged in a complex network of more and more law and regulation, which threatens not only to restrict but to criminalize journalists’ conduct.

Download
Policy Brief
A Royal Charter for the Press: How does it measure up to regulation overseas?

In this policy brief, published in conjunction with the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Lara Fielden examines the three key qualities Lord Justice Leveson recommended for future press regulation – that it is  ‘voluntary’, ‘independent’, and ‘self-regulatory’. These characteristics, which form the basis of the government’s draft Royal Charter, are explored within the instructive context of differing approaches to press regulation in a range of democracies overseas.

Download
Policy Brief
Private Rights and Public Responsibilities: Recent developments in Scots water law
Water law has been the subject of considerable attention in the Scottish Parliament since its re-establishment in 1999, with five Water Acts passed in that time. 
 
This policy brief examines these recent reforms and considers whether there has been a shift from private rights to private responsibilities, or perhaps, from private rights to public rights, over water resources in Scotland.
 
The brief will also consider what lessons may be learned in England from the introduction in Scotland of limited competition in retail
Download
Policy Brief
Press Regulation: Taking account of media convergence

This policy brief by media expert Lara Fielden proposes a radical new framework for press regulation based on a comparative study of international press councils, which addresses what Lord Justice Leveson has described as the 'elephant in the room' of the Leveson Inquiry: regulation of online media.

 

Download