Courts as Legislators: Supreme People’s Court Interpretations and Procedural Reforms
Randall Peerenboom
Peerenboom.pdf (259.51 KB)
Courts as Legislators: Supreme People’s Court Interpretations and Procedural Reforms

Courts in China today often act like legislative bodies, making law by issuing interpretations of laws that are binding on the courts. The general trend in China has been towards more transparency and greater public participation in legislative law-making and administrative rulemaking processes. In contrast, the judicial interpretation process is less transparent, with significantly less room for public participation.

The SPC should give teeth to the general reform recommendations in the Second Five-Year Agenda by promulgating detailed rules for hearings and a notice and comment system that provide the general public with a greater say in the drafting of interpretations and other quasi-legislative documents.
 
The need for a constitutional review body has been much debated in China. The creation of such a body is not within the power of the SPC. Nor is it likely to occur in the near future. Nevertheless, there is growing pressure to address the issue.
 
 
ALSO OF INTEREST
Policy Brief
China Labour Dispute Resolution

Economic growth and the transition to a market economy have strained the employment relationship, leading to rising disputes. Labour disputes grew between 1994 and 2006 from 19,098 to about 317,000, including 14,000 collective labour disputes involving 350,000 workers, or 51 per cent of the total workers involved in labour disputes. 

Download
Policy Brief
Traps, Gaps, and Law: Prospects and Challenges for China’s Reforms

It is unwarranted or too early to conclude that China’s transition is ‘trapped’, legally and politically. Judging the level of China’s political and legal reform and development, and whether it is adequate to the challenges it faces, is problematic.

Cross-national metrics for rule of law, good governance, economic inequality, and democracy tell us little about whether China’s level of legal development is consistent with continued growth and political stability.
 
 
Download
Policy Brief
China’s Transition and the Limits of the American Constitutional Perspective

The standard frameworks used to evaluate constitutional systems are not well suited to exposing transitional capacity. The constitutional problems that Minxin Pei’s Trapped in Transition focuses on do not reveal the system’s eventual capacity to transcend them.

Download
Judicial Independence in China: Introduction

This is the first book in English on judicial independence in China. This may not seem surprising given China remains an effectivelysingle-party socialist authoritarian state, the widely reported prosecutions of political dissidents and the conventional wisdom that China has never had independent courts.

Download